by S. L. Duncan
This week, Robert Galbraith was revealed to be a pseudonym
for J. K. Rowling, the true author of THE CUCKOO’S CALLING, a book that
‘debuted’ with Little Brown’s Mulholland Books on April 30th, 2013.
Until the unmasking, the book had sold a mere 1500 copies.
Decidedly bad news for any book at a big publisher.
Apparently THE SUNDAY TIMES of LONDON, which must have reporters
lining its halls, begging for stories to report, decided to investigate how a
debut novel could have been so confidently written and broke the story. Starred, for instance, and quite
gloriously, by Publisher’s Weekly, which insists of its ignorance about the
whole ruse. A careful trail of not-so-loosely connected evidence sent our intrepid reporter bounding
through London (did Dan Brown just roll his eyes?) back to Little, Brown, where it was discovered that the editor of THE CUCKOO’S
CALLING was, coincidentally, the same editor of THE CAUSAL VACANCY, Rowling's other Little Brown novel. Of course, there
are no coincidences, and this great mystery ended with the revelation of the Harry
Potter scribe as the author beneath the cloak of invisibility.
Now, whether or not you believe this all seems a bit too
good to be true, what does seem to be honest is how the book performed on the
market without a big name to push sales. It is
true the book received good reviews. And a star from PW always helps to sell
books. Yet, at the end of the day, the book only sold 1500 copies. Or 499, if
we’re going by Neilsen Bookscan.
After the revelation? THE CUCOO’S CALLING sits at#1 on
nearly every book list out there.
What we’ve just been subjected to is an amazing experiment
for the publishing industry. The Debut
vs. The Name (where quality of the story and writing are equal). And it seems there is an amazing separation of the two. Take
note, because if you are a debut author, this is the hill you’re climbing. You
could write like J. K. Rowling – hell, you could be J. K. Rowling – and regardless of your talent, or the brilliance
of your tale, you may be happy to get 1500 copies of your book out the door.
So without a name to rely on – and something tells me
“Robert Galbraith” wasn’t exactly making the blog rounds – it falls back to us
as the author to build a voice for our books on the market. Publishing, it
seems, is a slow handshake. A molasses introduction to win readers over and
gain their trust, until one day they can just look at your name and know yours
is a book they’d like to read.
What does remain constant, debut or superstar (and
everywhere in between), is the need for quality in the work. So write hard, friends, and
pay attention to all the wonderful advice on this blog about what you can do to
make your work stand out.
And if all else fails, legally change your name to Stephen
King or something.*
*That’s probably bad advice.
S. L. Duncan writes young adult fiction, including his debut, the first book in The Revelation Saga, due in 2014 from Medallion Press. You can find him blogging onINKROCK.com and on Twitter.